For day 13 of Better Speech and Hearing Month, I am discussing culturally sensitive SLP assessment tools. We will all have diverse identities on our caseloads, and our assessment tools need to reflect that. The tools I share will be as non-biased as possible, and test non-english based skills in the instance of linguistically diverse populations.
Aspects of Culturally Sensitive SLP Assessment
ASHA shares that “No test can be completely culture free. Most formal testing is unfamiliar to individuals who have not had exposure to the mainstream educational context and to the culture of testing that includes both nonverbal and verbal components. Nonverbal aspects of the testing culture include:
- perception of time;
- how one is expected to learn;
- how one is expected to respond—in a testing context—to the examiner, regardless of gender, culture, age, and/or socioeconomic background;
- attitudes toward display of abilities;
- attitudes toward guessing, using the process of elimination, storytelling, or conversing with an unfamiliar individual;
- test abstraction (e.g., naming protocols that require providing already shared information or situations in which the client/patient is required to assume a “make-believe” attitude in order to engage in an expected manner); and
- nonlinguistic aspects of pragmatics (DeJarnette, Rivers, & Hyter, 2015).
Verbal aspects of the testing culture include
- form of language;
- functions of language;
- content of language;
- organization of language; and
- pragmatic rules of social interaction.
ASHA recommendations using accommodations and modifications to testing material when possible:
- rewording and providing additional test instructions other than those allowed when presenting trial items;
- providing additional cues or repeating stimuli that may not be permitted on test or task items;
- allowing extra time for responses on timed subtests;
- skipping items that are inappropriate for the individual (e.g., items with which the client/patient has had no experience);
- asking the individual for an explanation of correct or incorrect responses (when not standard procedure); and
- using alternate scoring rubrics.
Culturally Sensitive SLP Asssessment Tools
Non-word repetition assessment task: These ask the patient or student to repeat nonwords of differing length and complexity. They are a type of dynamic assessment that can assess phonological working memory, speech perception, phonological assembly and short term memory. There are different NWRTs for many different languages. As a result, they are less culturally and linguistically biased. This is because they do not require background knowledge and can be modified for several languages.
Trans Women Voice Questionnaire (TWVQ):
The TWVQ is a self-evaluation questionnaire designed for use with women who were assigned male at birth and who identify and live full time as their authentic female gender. Its purpose is to measure the women’s experiences with their voices. The TWVQ is available for free download by speech-language pathologists/speech-language therapists, speech and voice researchers and trans women who wish to monitor or evaluate their own experiences with their voices. At the time of it’s development, the TWQV was named the Transsexual Voice Questionnaire (Male to female, TVQ MtF), With time and the ever-evolving language used in the trans and gender diverse space came sufficient report that the original title with it’s use of ‘transsexual’ and ‘male-to-female’, was considered by some as offensive. The name was officially changed in July 2020 and the authors feel confident that the name change has not compromised the integrity or the validity of the questionnaire. The best part is, it is available for free below. It is currently translated into sixteen languages and six more are being added.
Source: Resources, Communication Clinic, La Trobe University
Patterns of Strengths and Weaknesses Methodologies: IDEA allows two additional procedures for SLD eligibility. First, teams are allowed to examine student responsiveness to research-based interventions as a part of a process for
determining eligibility. Second, teams may use alternative, research-based methods to identify SLD. Alternative, research-based methods, sometimes known as “third method” approaches, incorporate examination of a student’s patterns of strengths and weaknesses in performance, achievement, or both relative to age, state-approved standards or intellectual development, patterns that are relevant to the identification of specific learning disabilities. A PSW focuses on the “why” if a child is not performing at the level they should be, rather than just the “if” they are performing at the right level or not. School psychologists will look at the IQ score and cognitive processes that contribute to the IQ. This also removes the language aspect by focusing on IQ and additionally finds the specific cognitive breakdowns that are occurring and can be targeted.
Culturally Responsive RTI: Compared to the general RTI, CR-RTI focuses on a culture and equity foundation. Additionally, it involves culture mediation of learning processes with culturally-responsive curriculum and interventions.
- Tier I: Universal Interventions Tier- includes culturally responsive curriculum for all students.
- Tier II: Secondary Interventions Tier- Ongoing assessments of curriculum appropriateness, learning environment, student progress and assessment practices.
- Tier III: Tertiary Interventions tier- Students get specialized instruction that may require students be eligible for special education.
Curriculum Based Measurement: These measures are taken directly from curriculum. They can be quickly prepped and adminstered and are more familiar to the student. A student could solve math problems or read a typical reading passage in their textbook.
Performance Based Assessment: This method uses projects that are aligned with classroom instruction to assess child’s strengths and weaknesses more functionally. It is more holistic and can have a rubric that reflects multiple areas of learning. Students can show their knowledge in multiple ways.
This was day 13 of Better Speech and Hearing month. We discussed culturally sensitive assessment tools.
If you missed the first twelve days of BHSM, click here to check them out.
Come back tomorrow to learn more about cultural sensitivity as an SLP. For more cultural sensitivity tips, make sure to subscribe to my SLP Survival Newsletter!